Business Daily Media

Australia may be engaging in 'free trade' but it's becoming more protectionist too

  • Written by Giovanni Di Lieto, Lecturer of international trade law, Monash Business School, Monash University

The federal government may be aggressively[1] negotiating free trade agreements, but in other ways it is restricting trade[2]. The government has been giving itself extensive new anti-dumping powers, targeting steel and aluminium markets[3] in particular.

There was a nearly two-fold[4] increase in anti-dumping investigations in Australia in 2017. According to the Productivity Commission[5], these protectionist measures “raise costs to consumers and reduce competitive pressures, leading to less efficient resource use in the country levying the protection”.

Higher tariffs lift the costs of imports and disrupt global supply chains. This harms consumers, producers and workers.

The Productivity Commission estimates[6] that for every A$1 increase in tariff revenue, economic activity in Australia falls by A$0.64. The commission also says that for “every year that higher tariffs prevailed, GDP would be lower by over one per cent”. Thus, “a household that spends A$2,500 a fortnight on goods and services would be worse off by A$100 a fortnight”.

Read more: Three charts on: G20 countries' stealth trade protectionism[7]

The Australian Department of Industry[8] explains that:

dumping occurs when goods exported to Australia are priced lower than their “normal value”, which is usually the comparable price in the ordinary course of trade in the exporter’s domestic market.

A recent example of this in action was when the Anti-Dumping Commission found[9] that major exporters of tinned Italian tomatoes were dumping their product in Australia. The government swiftly imposed dumping duties of up to 8.4%[10].

In principle, this is perfectly legitimate. World Trade Organisation agreements[11] allow these duties to be imposed when dumping or subsidisation threaten to cause material injury to a domestic industry.

But recent changes to Australia’s anti-dumping laws[12], while purportedly aimed at “levelling the field”, place a greater legal burden on overseas businesses with more stringent submission requirements.

Moreover, legislative proposals tabled in the federal parliament[13] in late 2017 could vastly expand the discretionary power the government has to set benchmark prices for imported products in the Australian market. These can even be set at higher levels than the prices in the home market from which they were exported.

Indeed, according to international trade law practitioners[14], “dumping duties at high rates will give the Minister an unprecedented price-fixing power over imported products, to the extent that foreign exporters and their Australian importers may be unable to compete in Australian markets”.

In other words, this proposal could exacerbate the trend[15] of covert trade protectionism in Australia.

According to a 2017 WTO report on trade measures in the G20 countries[16], new anti-dumping actions have outpaced terminations by three to one. This is the largest gap since 2012. Australia also had a fourfold increase in new countervailing duty measures (trade retaliations, in other words) from 2015 to 2016, second only to the USA. In 2016 Australia started nearly one-third of all G20 trade retaliations.

Australia may be engaging in 'free trade' but it's becoming more protectionist too Initiations of anti-dumping investigations in G20 countries (2016-17) World Trade Organization Australia may be engaging in 'free trade' but it's becoming more protectionist too Initiations of countervailing duty investigations in G20 countries (2015-16) World Trade Organization

The subjects of anti-dumping actions are usually technical barriers to trade that measurably affect certain industries. In the G20 countries most of these relate to agricultural policies.

Australia has in recent times[17] raised specific trade concerns about the European Union’s agriculture policies, India’s minimum prices for wheat and sugar, Canadian subsidies for milk and wine, and the United States’ purchase of cheese stock, export credit guarantees and international food aid.

Read more: In the economic power struggle for Asia, Trump and Xi Jinping are switching policies[18]

The anti-dumping data and legislative trends clearly show that Australia is at the forefront of the trend[19] towards greater (covert) trade protectionism among developed countries.

Several government policies, including the abolition of the temporary work 457 visas, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission’s exemption of certain foreign financial suppliers from particular regulatory requirements, and the Mobile Black Spot Program (to improve mobile coverage in regional and remote Australia) have also come under scrutiny by the World Trade Organisation[20]

This does not completely undermine Australia’s leadership in new free trade agreements in the Asia Pacific region and beyond. But it does show that Australian trade diplomacy is taking place within the creation of a less-than-liberal order of global economy[21].

Authors: Giovanni Di Lieto, Lecturer of international trade law, Monash Business School, Monash University

Read more http://theconversation.com/australia-may-be-engaging-in-free-trade-but-its-becoming-more-protectionist-too-92025

Business Reports

Airbnb reveals guests from Australia among most enthusiastic searchers for trips to Japan

As Japan reopens to the world for individual travel from the 11 October, Airbnb data has revealed guests from Australia, South Korea, the United States, Hong Kong and Singapore have generated the most searches to visit the land ...

Banks could save US$246 billion running a cloud-native core

A new report from Mambu and Celent shows banks need to invest in core platforms to improve performance and reduce costs Banks globally could save over US$240 billion by switching to the cloud, according to a new report from l...

Warning to Aussie Small Business After Optus Cyber Breach

Australian SMEs are being warned they’ve been left exposed after Optus hackers accessed the personal information of up to 10 million Australians.  “This is very serious and has the potential to create a business email co...

OZTENT SWAG WINS GOOD DESIGN AWARD

The Oztent Group has been awarded a Good Design Award for their OZTENT RS-2 Double Swag. The OZTENT RS-2 Double Swag is a world first.    It’s the only two-person swag that can be set up in less than 30 seconds.  Its...

Aussie shoppers use a phone in-store to research before buying

Bazaarvoice, Inc., the leading provider of product reviews and user-generated content (UGC) solutions, today released its latest research, based on a survey of more than 6,000 global shoppers and over 400 retailers. The report s...

Valerio Zanoli’s documentary HOMELESS

Film director and real estate entrepreneur Valerio Zanoli (www.valeriozanoli.com) has recently presented the first images of his latest work, the documentary HOMELESS, at the 2022 Statewide Conference on Ending Homelessness. T...

Web Busters - Break into local search

WebBusters.com.au