It ensures high-quality care is provided to a large number of children, it is targeted through income-based subsidies, and it is attentive to the needs of disadvantaged children and families.
But it has significant weaknesses.
It is extremely complex, with four different rates of subsidy based on the type of care involved, six different income thresholds plus a sliding scale for how household income affects the subsidy, an annual cap of $10,373 per child for households earning more than $188,163, and an activity test to determine eligibility.
Worse, many families find it hard to get good childcare. Children are added to waiting lists from birth.
And, as the Productivity Commission and others have pointed out, the sliding income scale and caps can mean that a parents looking to expand their working hours from 3 days to 4 days a week can face effective marginal tax rates approaching 100%.
This is not a good way to give parents choice about whether to work inside or outside of the home. By restricting (mainly female) choice it restricts the potential size of the workforce.
How to do it
- ^ pretty good (www.humanservices.gov.au)
- ^ based on the type of care involved (www.humanservices.gov.au)
- ^ six different income thresholds plus a sliding scale (www.humanservices.gov.au)
- ^ annual cap of $10,373 per child (www.humanservices.gov.au)
- ^ an activity test (www.humanservices.gov.au)
- ^ New childcare policy still leaves vulnerable families behind (theconversation.com)
- ^ have pointed out (www.pc.gov.au)
- ^ approaching 100% (www.theage.com.au)
- ^ women earn only 86% of what men do (www.wgea.gov.au)
- ^ one of the key reasons (papers.ssrn.com)
- ^ UNSW New Economic Policy Initiative (b536ef95-d95a-41ab-8ea2-86d91525afdc.filesusr.com)
- ^ New Economic Policy Initiative (www.neweconomicpolicy.com)
- ^ (Un)Taxing Childcare (cdn.theconversation.com)
- ^ 205,000 households better off (b536ef95-d95a-41ab-8ea2-86d91525afdc.filesusr.com)
- ^ Election FactCheck Q&A: does the government spend more on negative gearing and capital gains tax discounts than on child care or higher education? (theconversation.com)
Authors: Richard Holden, Professor of Economics, UNSW